Wednesday, 22 January 2014

The Act Of Killing - A Unsettling Depiction of a Mass Murderer


 The film opens with an image destined to become iconic with this surreal and at times harrowing documentary. It’s a strange ethereal dance sequence of sorts, and it moves forward to the filming of a similar scene, a man dressed as a priest looking told to look enlightened as dancers around him are told to smile, all taking place in a sublime and colourful waterfall filmed in a soft focus. Though far from being ‘Genocide the musical!’ The film does use typical Hollywood genres to a similarly disturbing effect that one could imagine from such an inappropriately named piece.  The film doesn’t, like something one might expect from the recent films of Quentin Tarantino, depict a fantasy version of humanities troubled history through the lens of an exploitation action movie. It instead documents the act of looking back and presenting something in a warped fashion. That’s where the comparisons with Tarantino end, where his films could come from a survivors attempt to redeem through falsehood, a vicious sense of morality applied, this has its eyes strictly off the victims and on the murderers. While Tarantino presents us with a world in which the Nazi’s get even more of a beating, The Act of Killing documents a society in which the mass murderers are treated as heroes, the real world. Already two themes found hand in hand make themselves clear, the fragility of truth and memory, and cinema’s ability to vent and inspire sadistic desires beyond the realms of the morally acceptable.  


 The film follows a group of ageing men, those who took part in the mass murder of accused communists in the 60’s Indonesia Military Coup. Apparently director Joshua Oppenheimer set out to make a documentary about the genocide, discovering that the survivors would not speak to him in fear of punishment, he was forced to go to those who took part in the killings, and would not only talk about their experiences but boast. The film would have been far less bold if it hadn’t got up close and personal with these men who could easily be seen as inhuman monsters, the shock factor comes in the fact that their very human indeed. Some are viler than others, and a whole host of characters that run through the documentary brings you close into a nightmarish world most would rather not experience.  The central character Anwar is a pleasant elderly gentleman, who was influenced by movie stars in his youth. He was a gangster that carried out hundreds of state validated murders, his funny fat friend who seems to be permanently dressed as a woman, was another mass murderer, and so the film continues getting closer and closer to the heart of their actions. Some characters are frighteningly immoral, one jokes about his raping of an underage girl. Though unrepentant, one of the most interesting things about these characters is that very few of them come out and say they believe what they did was right, it feels as though they try to avoid the issue of the morality of their own actions all together, preferring to douse their memories in the soothing waters of Hollywood cinema.  One even refuses to accept he knew what his friends were doing, and it’s disturbing to see him backed into the corner when his friends reason that it was impossible that this was the case.

This group is given the chance recreate their memories of these ‘heroic’ activities in the style of their favourite genres, such as gangsta films and westerns. They in there youth would work outside of cinemas showing American films, going from the films to torture their victims in their offices.  This association with Hollywood, and the gangsters’ attempts to mimic the heroes in these films, provides the director ample opportunity to make a comment about Cinemas influence. Indeed it’s the characters faux westernised sensibility that is this films most relevant comment, on how these characters adopted the sadism of cinema as they see it, and how they came to be there today smiling as they recount there astoundingly disturbing exploits in the most terrifyingly blasé way imaginable. It’s in their recreation of Hollywood styles applied to their own acts and warped self righteousness that draws their attention to how what they did was wrong by these same Hollywood standards, in the act of killing they find the truth of it, or at least another version of it. 

Their guilt is explored boldly by raising questions about humanity and memory. The Hollywood connection draws attention to the wests support of these murders, subtly raising this issue, America’s influence felt throughout the film. As is outlined by one of the killers, the winner defines what a war criminal is, history is what the winners says it is. The support of these murders and the consequent positive news coverage in some western countries, America included, brings us face to face with a warped reflection of our own society. By the end it holds its own with the likes of George Orwell’s 1984 in its ability to warn us not to accept it all so blindly, morality and all. The truly shocking reality of History’s instability in the face of propaganda resonates throughout The Act of Killing. 

There is a point to be made that the film is less about these flickering themes and more focused on the metaphysical exploration of ideas like identity, humanity and memory. The killers’ stories are never resolved but Anwar does start to understand the effect of his actions, seemingly shocked by the recreation of the massacre of a village and how “brutal” it looked. It’s his role as his own victim in the recreation that starts to have the biggest effect on him, “is this how my victims felt,” and by the end its clear he is not the same man that grinned while describing a more effective way of killing communists. There’s no resolution but it’s powerful. The film is a nightmarishly surreal descent into the act that is their lives, that of unapologetically happy killers that laugh as they describe their atrocious actions. It’s on the edge of ironic that the further they depth into their vision of their memories, the films and fantasy they have created for themselves and the filmmakers, the closer they come to the reality of what they have done and it’s effect on them.

A masterpiece of documentary filmmaking, the most vivid and powerful film this year, whatever label one gives The Act Of Killing we can be sure another like it will be hard to come by in the foreseeable future.  

Monday, 23 December 2013

Review - The Hobbit: The desolation of Smaug


The Hobbit: The desolation of Smaug has a mild tonal departure from the first film of Peter Jackson’s new trilogy, and is packed full of more action adventure and frolicking dwarfs than The Unexpected Journey, a tea party is replaced with a roller coaster like detour down a steep river. However despite this all, it fails to become any more captivating or involving that it’s predecessor.




The best thing in this film was the best film in the last film, Martin Freeman. His performance as the British chap in the strange place encapsulates the character of Bilbo Baggins, and is at risk of actually holding the film together (though not quite). It’s his scene with Smaug, as it was his scene with Gollum in the unexpected journey, (using the movement of Benedict Cumberbatch and Andy Serkis respectively), that starts to pull the film thematically together, that begins to instill actual emotion in it’s audience, before it again descends into a miserably drawn out CGI fest. Here in the arrival of the dragon into the story, ridiculously about two hours or so in, gives the film a sense of menace, the size and oppressive threat felt around the dragon highlights the best and really only good use of CGI in the entire film.  So what does this leave us with before this point? Being that there is a lot of CGI in this film. Personally I remain adamant that CGI detaches an audience when used in large doses, especially when creating images that we may have experience with ourselves. Creating a field, mountain, or excessive amount of movement using CGI is noticeable because an audience knows what this looks like in reality, whilst a dragon is believable because we do not.  It seems a waste that Peter Jackson films in a country that is essentially Middle Earth or the closest thing to it in reality, but stays in a green box filming a dwarf in a barrel, instead of exploring the beautiful landscapes at his fingertips. This is the major departure from the tone of his previous trilogy, the well-made Lord of the Rings, this and all that it allows, dwarf slapstick not being the least of it. My praise of Freeman’s performance does not condemn the other actors in the hobbit. In fact it’s difficult to name a bad performance, but these actors are left wondering in a convoluted plot, with poor dialogue, and detached performances barely held together by the streams of CGI assaulting the eye.


The biggest problem with the Desolation of Smaug in the noticeable lack of structure and a tight narrative, Lord of Rings often gained criticism for it’s lack of restraint, but in the light of The Hobbit trilogy it feels just about as restrained as film can be. Though a similar length, the latter trilogy tells a clear story with a wealth of interesting characters and themes to explore. In the Desolation of Smaug Jackson tries do the same. Having to create a whole host of characters from the smallest details in the book, as a result much of the character development seems shoehorned in. Characters are left wandering in an unfocused narrative, surrounded by bizarre love triangles, daft wigs, and prosthetics. Another issues is the dialogue, the slightly jarring and cliché script was accepted in The Lord Of The Rings as it seemed to tie into the sense of grandeur and epic. But with this sense lacking in The Hobbit, and with the tone taking on a slapstick adventure gloss the script feels noticeably poor. The love triangle was particularly odd. Introducing a new female character seemed to be a good idea in a narrative sorely lacking in any strong women, however it seems ridiculous and slightly insulting that Jackson’s only idea of how to tie her into the story strongly is to introduce her in a love triangle with Legolas the Elf (on loan from the Lord Of The Rings trilogy) and a dwarf. This is one of the many things that may leave you feeling awkward and uninvolved with the new addition of Jackson’s trilogy. This and the film’s seemingly desperate inability to involve the audience will have the running time grind on any one over twelve.


It seems that Jackson can now be added to the growing list of directors whose vision is better constrained by budget and technology, whose production could do with someone telling him that there is a line. The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug is noticeably a film without a trace of a line, a million dollar egotistical splurge without a smidgen of self-control.  Can’t wait for the extended addition. 

Wednesday, 9 October 2013

The Middle Man: Why Marvel's Agents of Shield is neither here nor there


Recently, Marvel’s attempt on expanding their universe into a TV show format, ‘Marvel’s Agents of SHIELD’, has received mixed reactions. The show itself is as light and enjoyable as promised so why the violent backlash, amongst many fans. Well, the reason could be the growing divide between TV and Film, and not in a way that you might expect. With TV shows like Breaking Bad and Mad Men marking the beginning of a golden age of adult television, that quality is necessary for the success of a new show is undeniable. So is this the cause, a show can live or die on the promise and brilliance of the pilot, and a continued quality in a the very least the first series is needed for long lasting interest, just look at short lived phenomena Flash Forward. Agents of Shield is no Breaking Bad, so perhaps its failure to compete on an intellectual or even on a gripping level is to blame for the recent displeasure of the fans.  Arguably yes but it is also something more, Television has become the place for high concept ideas driven storytelling, free for the most part from the creatively crippling need to target the largest audience in the film industry. The truth is TV has become more than a format. Look at Agents of Shield, the self confessed geek culture grows and any one among them would agree to having fallen in love with a show like Breaking Bad, whilst also loving a film like Avengers Assemble. Not to say Avengers is in anyway a bad film, but inarguably it cannot compete on either an intellectual level nor even arguably an entertainment level with Breaking Bad, so why turn on Agents of shield a show that replicates the tone and style of Avengers Assemble with joyful glee. Perhaps it is simply a case of wanting your home life to stay at home, and your professional life at work, is it too cruel to say that the average moviegoer has just come to accept the decreased standard of quality in big budget filmmaking, whilst if this popcorn munching empty entertainment was to encroach unwelcome into the realm of a format that has done and can do better without even attempting to change it will not be welcomed with open arms. So what is it with the movie industry? As Walter White of Breaking Bad fame aptly outs it 'I'm not in the meth business. I'm in the empire business.' While not talking about the big budget Hollywood film industry there, he might as well have been. No longer is it in the film business but a universe building business. Rarely do you see a high concept standalone picture, now it is either a franchise or part of a wider cinematic universe. Now an audience not longer wants a constricted and selective view, now the viewer wants the entire world built around them a sandpit to play in. This is happening everywhere, with franchises like Harry Potter and Star Wars joining the bandwagon. So maybe the average viewer can accept a lesser standard of individual films if they expect it to only be a single piece in a magnificent jigsaw. So does this work for Television, certainly AMC shows like the walking dead and breaking bad are expanding their own universes with spin off shows and the concept of the jigsaw can be applied to the format itself, so if it’s not this that doesn’t fit together for Agents of Shield then again it must be brought to quality and the difference of experience. It brings its budget, its entertainment value, and carries behind it enough movie baggage to fill a jumbo jet, yet much of it is un-cinematic compared to the films, but not the standard of TV we’ve grown used to, could it simply not belong anywhere in the viewers mind. So is it just the case we don’t want our worlds of guilty pleasures and serious dramas colliding in an awkward compromise, or is it just a lacklustre TV show that the fans don’t love. Or maybe it’s too early to decide and people should stop getting worked up over a pilot episode of a show that hasn’t really had a chance.

Thursday, 11 July 2013

Edgar Wright: Is his future exclusive to Hollywood?


Director Edgar Wright made his name in British cult TV comedy ‘Spaced’, but now with the unofficial film trilogy extension of the program finally coming to a close in the summer comedy ‘World’s End’, we ask if the future for Mr Wright’s sparkling career will be under the shadow of the Hollywood sign.  

Hollywood has well and truly got Edgar Wright on its radar. 2010’s ‘Scott Pilgrim vs. The World’ was Wright’s first foray into more American filmmaking. Luckily for fans of the director’s very distinctive auteur style, Scott Pilgrim was a film which more than just carried across what made Wright unique in Britain, it emphases it. The film’s quick stylish pace, retaining the comic book style of the graphic novel it was based on, had never been done to such an extent on the big screen, making it a unique and therefore risky film in the modern Hollywood market.  Though not overwhelmingly successful financially the film seemed to be destined to achieve cult classic status, Wright proving himself as a lord of modern pop culture. The fact is that Wright’s very particular kind of filmmaking is not restricted to any country, it simply works. 

So now with Wright’s final film in the very British three flavoured Cornetto trilogy (or the blood and ice cream trilogy) finally released, is wright’s future in film exclusively Hollywood? The one film currently on his horizon,  ‘Ant Man’ is part of Marvel Superhero franchise. If test footage is anything to go by the superhero character is a perfect match with Wright’s zappy style, but still it’s a superhero film, ultimate Hollywood blockbuster material. So is that it for small quirky British comedies like ‘Shaun of the Dead’, and ‘Hot Fuzz’. Even ‘World’s end’ an incredibly British story of the ultimate Pub Crawl is in more of a Hollywood tint then it’s predecessors, as the Telegraph says, “Wright slyly alters the film’s visual texture from social-realist grain to Hollywood gloss”. So is the ‘World’s End’ Wright’s farewell to British fare. The incredibly British sensibility of Wright’s Cornetto trilogy suggests not.  The idea of a good British pub always seems to be prominent in all three films, in a zombie apocalypse go to the pub, it verges of farcical but Wright lovingly presents us with the quirks of British society and habits. Clearly he carries love for the viewpoint of Britishness he seen in his films. So will he leave all that and never return to his roots, personally I can’t see him never again making a distinctively British film, at heart he is still a very British director.