The film opens with an image
destined to become iconic with this surreal and at times harrowing documentary.
It’s a strange ethereal dance sequence of sorts, and it moves forward to the
filming of a similar scene, a man dressed as a priest looking told to look
enlightened as dancers around him are told to smile, all taking place in a
sublime and colourful waterfall filmed in a soft focus. Though far from being
‘Genocide the musical!’ The film does use typical Hollywood genres to a similarly
disturbing effect that one could imagine from such an inappropriately named
piece. The film doesn’t, like something
one might expect from the recent films of Quentin Tarantino, depict a fantasy
version of humanities troubled history through the lens of an exploitation
action movie. It instead documents the act of looking back and presenting
something in a warped fashion. That’s where the comparisons with Tarantino end,
where his films could come from a survivors attempt to redeem through
falsehood, a vicious sense of morality applied, this has its eyes strictly off
the victims and on the murderers. While Tarantino presents us with a world in
which the Nazi’s get even more of a beating, The Act of Killing documents a
society in which the mass murderers are treated as heroes, the real world.
Already two themes found hand in hand make themselves clear, the fragility of
truth and memory, and cinema’s ability to vent and inspire sadistic desires
beyond the realms of the morally acceptable.
The
film follows a group of ageing men, those who took part in the mass murder of
accused communists in the 60’s Indonesia Military Coup. Apparently director
Joshua Oppenheimer set out to make a documentary about the genocide,
discovering that the survivors would not speak to him in fear of punishment, he
was forced to go to those who took part in the killings, and would not only
talk about their experiences but boast. The film would have been far less bold
if it hadn’t got up close and personal with these men who could easily be seen
as inhuman monsters, the shock factor comes in the fact that their very human
indeed. Some are viler than others, and a whole host of characters that run
through the documentary brings you close into a nightmarish world most would
rather not experience. The central
character Anwar is a pleasant elderly gentleman, who was influenced by movie
stars in his youth. He was a gangster that carried out hundreds of state
validated murders, his funny fat friend who seems to be permanently dressed as
a woman, was another mass murderer, and so the film continues getting closer
and closer to the heart of their actions. Some characters are frighteningly
immoral, one jokes about his raping of an underage girl. Though unrepentant,
one of the most interesting things about these characters is that very few of
them come out and say they believe what they did was right, it feels as though
they try to avoid the issue of the morality of their own actions all together,
preferring to douse their memories in the soothing waters of Hollywood
cinema. One even refuses to accept he
knew what his friends were doing, and it’s disturbing to see him backed into
the corner when his friends reason that it was impossible that this was the
case.
This
group is given the chance recreate their memories of these ‘heroic’ activities
in the style of their favourite genres, such as gangsta films and westerns.
They in there youth would work outside of cinemas showing American films, going
from the films to torture their victims in their offices. This association with Hollywood, and the gangsters’
attempts to mimic the heroes in these films, provides the director ample opportunity
to make a comment about Cinemas influence. Indeed it’s the characters faux
westernised sensibility that is this films most relevant comment, on how these
characters adopted the sadism of cinema as they see it, and how they came to be
there today smiling as they recount there astoundingly disturbing exploits in
the most terrifyingly blasé way imaginable. It’s in their recreation of
Hollywood styles applied to their own acts and warped self righteousness that
draws their attention to how what they did was wrong by these same Hollywood
standards, in the act of killing they find the truth of it, or at least another
version of it.
Their
guilt is explored boldly by raising questions about humanity and memory. The
Hollywood connection draws attention to the wests support of these murders,
subtly raising this issue, America’s influence felt throughout the film. As is
outlined by one of the killers, the winner defines what a war criminal is, history
is what the winners says it is. The support of these murders and the consequent
positive news coverage in some western countries, America included, brings us
face to face with a warped reflection of our own society. By the end it holds
its own with the likes of George Orwell’s 1984 in its ability to warn us not to
accept it all so blindly, morality and all. The truly shocking reality of History’s
instability in the face of propaganda resonates throughout The Act of Killing.
There is a point to be made that the film is less
about these flickering themes and more focused on the metaphysical exploration
of ideas like identity, humanity and memory. The killers’ stories are never resolved
but Anwar does start to understand the effect of his actions, seemingly shocked
by the recreation of the massacre of a village and how “brutal” it looked. It’s
his role as his own victim in the recreation that starts to have the biggest
effect on him, “is this how my victims felt,” and by the end its clear he is
not the same man that grinned while describing a more effective way of killing
communists. There’s no resolution but it’s powerful. The film is a
nightmarishly surreal descent into the act that is their lives, that of
unapologetically happy killers that laugh as they describe their atrocious
actions. It’s on the edge of ironic that the further they depth into their
vision of their memories, the films and fantasy they have created for themselves
and the filmmakers, the closer they come to the reality of what they have done
and it’s effect on them.
A masterpiece of documentary filmmaking, the most
vivid and powerful film this year, whatever label one gives The Act Of Killing we can be sure another
like it will be hard to come by in the foreseeable future.



