Monday, 23 December 2013

Review - The Hobbit: The desolation of Smaug


The Hobbit: The desolation of Smaug has a mild tonal departure from the first film of Peter Jackson’s new trilogy, and is packed full of more action adventure and frolicking dwarfs than The Unexpected Journey, a tea party is replaced with a roller coaster like detour down a steep river. However despite this all, it fails to become any more captivating or involving that it’s predecessor.




The best thing in this film was the best film in the last film, Martin Freeman. His performance as the British chap in the strange place encapsulates the character of Bilbo Baggins, and is at risk of actually holding the film together (though not quite). It’s his scene with Smaug, as it was his scene with Gollum in the unexpected journey, (using the movement of Benedict Cumberbatch and Andy Serkis respectively), that starts to pull the film thematically together, that begins to instill actual emotion in it’s audience, before it again descends into a miserably drawn out CGI fest. Here in the arrival of the dragon into the story, ridiculously about two hours or so in, gives the film a sense of menace, the size and oppressive threat felt around the dragon highlights the best and really only good use of CGI in the entire film.  So what does this leave us with before this point? Being that there is a lot of CGI in this film. Personally I remain adamant that CGI detaches an audience when used in large doses, especially when creating images that we may have experience with ourselves. Creating a field, mountain, or excessive amount of movement using CGI is noticeable because an audience knows what this looks like in reality, whilst a dragon is believable because we do not.  It seems a waste that Peter Jackson films in a country that is essentially Middle Earth or the closest thing to it in reality, but stays in a green box filming a dwarf in a barrel, instead of exploring the beautiful landscapes at his fingertips. This is the major departure from the tone of his previous trilogy, the well-made Lord of the Rings, this and all that it allows, dwarf slapstick not being the least of it. My praise of Freeman’s performance does not condemn the other actors in the hobbit. In fact it’s difficult to name a bad performance, but these actors are left wondering in a convoluted plot, with poor dialogue, and detached performances barely held together by the streams of CGI assaulting the eye.


The biggest problem with the Desolation of Smaug in the noticeable lack of structure and a tight narrative, Lord of Rings often gained criticism for it’s lack of restraint, but in the light of The Hobbit trilogy it feels just about as restrained as film can be. Though a similar length, the latter trilogy tells a clear story with a wealth of interesting characters and themes to explore. In the Desolation of Smaug Jackson tries do the same. Having to create a whole host of characters from the smallest details in the book, as a result much of the character development seems shoehorned in. Characters are left wandering in an unfocused narrative, surrounded by bizarre love triangles, daft wigs, and prosthetics. Another issues is the dialogue, the slightly jarring and clichĂ© script was accepted in The Lord Of The Rings as it seemed to tie into the sense of grandeur and epic. But with this sense lacking in The Hobbit, and with the tone taking on a slapstick adventure gloss the script feels noticeably poor. The love triangle was particularly odd. Introducing a new female character seemed to be a good idea in a narrative sorely lacking in any strong women, however it seems ridiculous and slightly insulting that Jackson’s only idea of how to tie her into the story strongly is to introduce her in a love triangle with Legolas the Elf (on loan from the Lord Of The Rings trilogy) and a dwarf. This is one of the many things that may leave you feeling awkward and uninvolved with the new addition of Jackson’s trilogy. This and the film’s seemingly desperate inability to involve the audience will have the running time grind on any one over twelve.


It seems that Jackson can now be added to the growing list of directors whose vision is better constrained by budget and technology, whose production could do with someone telling him that there is a line. The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug is noticeably a film without a trace of a line, a million dollar egotistical splurge without a smidgen of self-control.  Can’t wait for the extended addition. 

No comments:

Post a Comment